Skip to main content

In Short

What this appraisal is for

Insurers need replacement value, not fair market value — the difference matters, and using the wrong basis is why claims get underpaid. We document what it would actually cost to replace an item, whether you're scheduling valuables on a policy up front or substantiating a claim after a theft, fire, or loss.

When You Need One

Who this is for

Insurance turns on a different number from every other appraisal, and that difference is why claims get underpaid. Clients reach us at two moments: before a loss, and after one.

  • An insurer or broker wants valuables scheduled on a policy, and needs a written appraisal for each.
  • A policy has a per-item limit that your jewelry, art, or collection has outgrown.
  • An appraisal on file is years old and no longer reflects what replacement costs.
  • A theft, a fire, or a water loss has happened, and the claim needs substantiating.
  • A collection has grown steadily and has never been documented as a whole.

Scope

What we appraise, and what we do not

What we appraise

  • Jewelry, watches, fine art, antiques, and collections being scheduled on a policy
  • Household contents being documented before a loss, or substantiated after one
  • Vehicles and equipment carried on a personal or a commercial policy

What we do not

  • The building, the structure, and anything attached to it — a dwelling is the real estate appraiser's work, not ours
  • Negotiating with your insurer. We are not a public adjuster and we do not act as one
  • Real estate of any kind — houses, land, and buildings are outside this practice

The Report

What the report is used for

Insurance uses replacement value: what it would cost to obtain a comparable item today, in the market where you would actually have to buy it. Fair market value — the figure an estate or a donation uses — is usually lower, and a policy written against it leaves you short at the worst possible moment.

Each report is signed and certified under USPAP, and states which standard of value it applies and why. Adjusters read that statement first, so it is not a formality.

  • A description of each item, with the marks, materials, and measurements that identify it
  • The replacement value of each item, and the total
  • The market the replacement figure is drawn from
  • The effective date of value
  • The appraiser's certification, qualifications, and signature

How It Works

Four steps, start to signed report

Most assignments are prepared remotely, from photographs and documents. Where an item genuinely has to be seen in person, we say so before you pay rather than issue an opinion we cannot stand behind.

  1. You send photographs and an inventory of the items, with any provenance, receipts, or certificates you have
  2. We reply with a fixed quote, before any work starts
  3. We research comparable sales and market data for each item or asset
  4. You receive a signed, USPAP-compliant report you can file

Your Part

What we need from you

  • Photographs of each piece from several angles
  • Close photographs of every hallmark, signature, serial number, and inscription
  • The grading report or laboratory certificate for any gemstone or diamond
  • Receipts, prior appraisals, and certificates of authenticity you already hold
  • What the insurer or broker has asked for, and any per-item limit in the policy

Photograph each piece from several angles, and photograph every hallmark, signature, serial number, and inscription close up. For gemstones and diamonds, send the grading report or laboratory certificate that came with the stone. Value there turns on characteristics no photograph can establish, so that document is what makes a remote appraisal possible for those items.

Price

What this costs

Contents and jewelry are quoted on the per-item schedule, from $10 an item for ordinary goods up to $50–75 for fine jewelry and significant pieces, with a $150 minimum. A vehicle or a machine on the same policy is quoted on the asset schedule, from $250.

You get a fixed quote before any work starts, and the fee follows the research the assignment takes, not the value we find. If photographs cannot support the value, we say so before you pay — and if the fee would exceed what the property is likely worth, we say that too.

Independence

Robert Porter does not buy or sell the property he appraises and does not take a commission.

Questions

Asked most often about insurance appraisal

What is the difference between replacement value and fair market value?
Replacement value is what it costs to obtain a comparable item today. Fair market value is what the item would sell for between a willing buyer and a willing seller. Insurers work in the first, courts and the IRS in the second, and the two figures are rarely the same. The purpose of the appraisal decides which one applies.
How often should an insurance appraisal be updated?
Markets move, and precious metals move fastest. Most insurers and brokers ask for a review every few years, and your policy or your broker is the authority on what yours requires. Come back sooner if the market for what you own has moved sharply.
Can you appraise an item that is already lost or destroyed?
Often, yes — if the record of what it was is good enough. Photographs, receipts, a prior appraisal, or documentation can support a value. We state exactly what the opinion rests on, and if the evidence is too thin to support a credible figure, we say so rather than guess.
Do you appraise houses or land?
No. This practice covers personal property, vehicles, boats, and equipment only. Real estate is a separate discipline under a separate licence, and we do not take that work. If you need a house or a parcel valued, a licensed real estate appraiser is who you want.
Do you appraise cars, boats, and equipment?
Yes. Vehicles, vessels, and machinery are part of the practice, alongside household contents. They are quoted on a separate asset schedule rather than on the per-item household tiers, because a car takes the research a car takes however many other items are on the list.
What do you need for jewelry?
The grading report, laboratory documentation, or certificate that came with the stone, along with close photographs of every hallmark and inscription. Value in gemstones and diamonds turns on characteristics no photograph can establish, so that document is what makes a remote appraisal possible.

Read the general FAQs for how remote appraisal works, what we need from you, and how long it takes.

Get Started

Request a quote

Tell us what needs appraising and what the appraisal is for. You get a fixed quote back before any work starts.

You can also call (727) 284-6493 or email contact@everythingappraised.com .

Call (727) 284-6493

No link is needed to get a quote. If your photos are not online yet, send them by email when we reply.

We do not appraise real estate. House and land appraisals are outside our work.

Quote requests are answered the same or following business day, Eastern Time.

Elsewhere On The Site

The appraisal you need may be a different one

By purpose

By asset

  • Vehicle Appraisal Certified values for cars, trucks, classic vehicles, and motorcycles — for insurance, donation, an estate, or a divorce.
  • Boat & Watercraft Appraisal Certified values for boats and watercraft — for insurance, donation, an estate, or a divorce.
  • Equipment & Machinery Appraisal Certified values for equipment and machinery — for insurance, a donation, or an estate.

See all appraisal services